How Britain Rediscovered Jazz

The Mercury Music Prize is in Newcastle this year. It has always had a weird relationship with jazz.

Every year, or so it seems, the judges include a jazz or folk album on the shortlist, presumably to demonstrate that their musical tastes extend beyond the latest fashionable bland indie bands and corporate pop stars. The records are usually excellent, although there has often been a suspicion that their principal function is to make up the numbers rather than provide a serious contender for the prize.

This year, the Newcastle band Knats have been nominated for their album A Great Day in Newcastle, which is particularly appropriate given that the Mercury ceremony is being held in the city. But their nomination is interesting for reasons that extend well beyond the prize itself. Over the last decade, something remarkable has been happening to British jazz, as a generation of musicians has combined the improvisation and musicianship of traditional jazz with jungle, garage, hip-hop, grime and the wider musical inheritance of Britain’s Black communities. The result is music that sounds quite unlike the American jazz that dominated the genre for much of the twentieth century.

Knats are part of that development, although their music has a distinctly North Eastern character, incorporating rock and spoken word alongside the rhythms of contemporary dance music. Meanwhile, Ezra Collective have released Here Because of Hope, and Moses Boyd’s Songs for Sinners arrives at the end of October. Three albums from musicians associated with the same broad movement, but each approaching jazz from a rather different direction.

It isn’t just that jazz appears has become fashionable again. This happens every so often. It’s that British musicians are doing something to jazz that an earlier generation did to blues and rock and roll, absorbing a musical form developed in America and transforming it through their own experiences and influences. And in both cases, immigration and the extraordinary musical diversity it helped create in Britain have played an important part.

From Orwell to the Beatles

In 1941, George Orwell published The Lion and the Unicorn, his examination of English national character written while Britain was fighting for its survival. Among his observations was the suggestion that the English were not as musical as the Germans or Italians, a judgement that seems almost extraordinary when viewed from the perspective of the following eighty-five years.

Just twenty-two years later, the Beatles released Please Please Me, and within another year they had conquered America. The Rolling Stones, the Who, the Kinks and countless others followed, establishing a period of British dominance in international popular music that would have seemed almost unimaginable when Orwell was writing. Britain went from being a musical backwater to becoming one of the principal centres of the global popular music industry.

I’ve written before how that transformation happened. The conventional explanation concentrates on the arrival of American rock and roll, rhythm and blues and the influence of performers such as Elvis Presley, Chuck Berry and Little Richard. British musicians initially copied the records they heard coming from America, but gradually developed their own approaches to songwriting, recording and performance. Eventually, the relationship was reversed, with American musicians increasingly looking towards Britain for inspiration.

But this is only part of the story. Post-war immigration, particularly from the Caribbean, introduced musical traditions that became increasingly important to British popular culture. Reggae, ska, calypso and the soundsystem culture that accompanied them interacted with American soul, blues and jazz, as well as existing British musical traditions. These influences didn’t simply produce British versions of music from elsewhere. They helped create new forms of music that subsequently spread around the world.

The Beatles and the Rolling Stones weren’t products of Caribbean immigration in the way that later British musical movements would be; their immediate influences were overwhelmingly American, particularly African American music. But the wider transformation of British popular music over the following decades is difficult to understand without recognising the contribution of immigration and the cultural exchanges it encouraged.

What Britain became particularly good at was absorbing music from elsewhere, combining it with other influences and producing something sufficiently distinctive to be exported back to the rest of the world. The new British jazz movement is another step in that process.

The Music is Black

Earlier this year, the V&A opened The Music is Black: A British Story, an exhibition examining the contribution of Black musicians and communities to British music over the last 125 years. It provides a useful historical context for understanding what has happened to jazz, because it demonstrates just how much of the music we now regard as distinctively British emerged from the interaction of different cultures.

The exhibition traces a history that extends well beyond the familiar story of the Windrush generation, examining the contribution of Black performers to British musical life before the Second World War as well as the extraordinary developments that followed. Its central argument is that Black music hasn’t simply influenced British popular culture from the margins. It has been one of the principal forces shaping that culture, producing musical forms that subsequently achieved international influence.

Consider the development of jungle during the early 1990s. Its origins lay partly in Caribbean soundsystem culture, particularly reggae and dub, but also in American house, techno and hip-hop, combined with the possibilities created by electronic music production. These influences came together in British clubs, pirate radio stations and recording studios to produce something genuinely new. Jungle wasn’t simply an imported American or Caribbean genre. It was a British musical invention, reflecting the experiences and cultural influences of the communities that created it.

Much the same can be said of drum and bass, UK garage and grime. Each emerged from a different combination of influences, but all were shaped by the interaction of Black British culture with musical developments elsewhere. They subsequently became part of Britain’s international musical identity, influencing performers and producers around the world.

This is an important distinction because it challenges the idea that immigration simply introduces foreign cultural traditions into an otherwise established national culture. What happened in British music was considerably more interesting. The arrival of new musical influences changed the existing culture, creating opportunities for experimentation and producing entirely new forms of music.

And it is this accumulated musical inheritance that the current generation of British jazz musicians has been drawing upon.

Britain’s earlier jazz revolutions

Jazz itself has a long history in Britain, although for much of the twentieth century the most important developments in the music came from America. British musicians looked towards performers such as Duke Ellington, Charlie Parker, Miles Davis and John Coltrane, interpreting their music and developing their own approaches to improvisation. There were important exceptions, including Joe Harriott, whose experiments with free-form jazz during the 1960s demonstrated that British musicians were capable of producing genuinely original work.

The relationship between jazz and Britain’s Black communities became increasingly important during the following decades. Caribbean-born musicians and their descendants brought different rhythmic and musical traditions into British jazz, while the jazz-funk scene of the late 1970s and early 1980s developed a substantial following in clubs. DJs such as Gilles Peterson helped establish connections between jazz, funk, soul and dance music, creating an audience that didn’t necessarily regard jazz as something to be listened to sitting quietly in a concert hall.

During the 1980s, the Jazz Warriors, a collective associated with musicians including Courtney Pine and Gary Crosby, developed a distinctly British approach to jazz that incorporated Caribbean influences and challenged some of the conventions of the established scene. Their music was part of a wider development in which Black British musicians were increasingly confident about drawing on their own cultural experiences rather than simply reproducing American jazz traditions.

Acid jazz followed towards the end of the decade, reaching a much larger audience during the 1990s. At first the name was a joke, a play on Acid House. But artists such as the Brand New Heavies, and Incognito created something genuinely new, even if they were overshadowed by Jamiroquai, the prat in the hat. The music combined elements of jazz with funk, soul and dance rhythms, often producing records that were considerably more successful commercially than conventional jazz releases.

But there was an important difference between acid jazz and what has happened more recently. Much of the acid jazz movement was essentially funk and soul incorporating jazz influences, while the current generation has approached the relationship from the opposite direction. These are accomplished jazz musicians who have incorporated the rhythmic and production techniques of jungle, garage, grime and hip-hop into their compositions and improvisations.

There is also a direct connection between the two generations. In 1991, Gary Crosby and Janine Irons established Tomorrow’s Warriors, an organisation intended to provide opportunities for talented young musicians, particularly those from communities underrepresented in jazz. Over the following decades, it helped develop an extraordinary collection of performers, including Shabaka Hutchings, Nubya Garcia, Moses Boyd and musicians associated with Ezra Collective.

That connection is particularly significant because it demonstrates that the current movement didn’t simply emerge from nowhere. Musicians who had helped establish a distinctively British jazz identity during the 1980s created an institution that supported the next generation, providing training, performance opportunities and connections between young performers. The musical developments of the last decade owe something to the foundations laid thirty years earlier.

We Out Here

If there was a moment when the new British jazz movement became recognisable as something more than a collection of individual musicians, it was probably the release of We Out Here in February 2018.

The compilation was released by Gilles Peterson’s Brownswood Recordings and brought together many of the musicians who had been developing their music through London’s jazz scene. Recorded over a few days under the musical direction of Shabaka Hutchings, it featured contributions from Nubya Garcia, Moses Boyd, Ezra Collective, Theon Cross, Kokoroko and others who would subsequently become leading figures in contemporary British jazz. This would be the first time I ever heard most of these bands.

The importance of We Out Here wasn’t simply that it introduced a collection of talented musicians to a wider audience. It demonstrated that something genuinely distinctive was happening in British jazz, with performers drawing on a shared musical environment while developing quite different approaches to composition and improvisation. The musicians frequently played together, appeared on one another’s records and developed their ideas through the same venues, clubs and organisations.

Listening to the album now, it’s striking how varied the music is. There are influences from spiritual jazz, Afrobeat, reggae and dub, alongside the rhythmic complexity of contemporary dance music. Some tracks are relatively restrained, while others are built around powerful rhythms that seem designed for dancing rather than contemplation. What connects them isn’t a particular musical formula, but an approach to jazz that treats the genre as something to be developed rather than preserved.

The album also helped establish a wider identity for the movement. Before We Out Here, many of the musicians were already attracting attention, but the compilation made it possible to recognise them as part of a broader development in British music. It was followed by increasing international interest, larger audiences and a growing number of successful recordings.

I think We Out Here deserves to be regarded as a turning point in British jazz, rather than simply an interesting compilation. It brought together the musicians, influences and attitudes that would define much of the music over the following decade, while providing a platform from which individual performers could develop their own careers.

There is also something particularly interesting about the circumstances in which the record was made. Unlike many contemporary recordings, assembled through electronic production and contributions recorded separately, We Out Here emerged from musicians playing together in a studio. The result retained the spontaneity and interaction associated with traditional jazz, while incorporating influences that had developed through several decades of electronic dance music.

In that sense, the album demonstrated how jazz could absorb contemporary British musical culture without abandoning the qualities that made it jazz in the first place.

Jazz for the dance floor

The musicians associated with We Out Here subsequently took the music in different directions, although they continued to share an approach that was unusually open to influences from outside jazz.

Shabaka Hutchings developed several projects, including Sons of Kemet, whose music incorporated Caribbean rhythms, African influences and political themes. Nubya Garcia drew on dub, reggae and spiritual jazz, developing a sound that was recognisably her own while remaining connected to the wider movement. Yussef Dayes brought a similarly adventurous approach to drumming, incorporating influences from funk, hip-hop and electronic music.

Moses Boyd is particularly interesting because his music demonstrates how thoroughly the rhythmic innovations of British dance music have become part of contemporary jazz. Boyd is an accomplished jazz drummer, but his playing and production also draw on jungle, drum and bass, grime and the Caribbean soundsystem tradition. These aren’t simply additional influences introduced to make jazz more accessible. They are part of the musical environment in which he developed, and consequently form an integral part of his approach to composition.

His 2020 album Dark Matter, which was shortlisted for the Mercury Prize, demonstrated how successfully these influences could be combined. The music moved between jazz improvisation, electronic production and dance rhythms without seeming particularly concerned about where one genre ended and another began.

Ezra Collective have followed a rather different path, developing an increasingly accessible combination of jazz, Afrobeat, hip-hop, reggae and contemporary soul. Their live performances are exuberant affairs, often resembling dance music events rather than conventional jazz concerts, and their records have attracted audiences considerably larger than those normally associated with British jazz.

In 2023, they became the first jazz group to win the Mercury Prize, with Where I’m Meant to Be. It was an important moment because it suggested that the movement had moved beyond the traditional jazz audience and established itself within the wider British music scene.

The band’s success also challenges some of the assumptions that have surrounded jazz for much of the last half-century. Jazz is frequently portrayed as difficult, intellectual music, appreciated by relatively small audiences who value technical accomplishment and improvisation. But jazz began as popular music, closely associated with dancing and entertainment, and much of the new British movement has rediscovered that relationship.

There is something rather satisfying about the idea that incorporating jungle and garage might have helped jazz recover some of the characteristics that made it popular in the first place.

And now Newcastle

Which brings us back to Knats, whose Mercury nomination provides the immediate reason for writing about all this.

Knats are part of the wider movement, but their music is sufficiently different from that of Ezra Collective or Moses Boyd to demonstrate how much the scene has developed. Their album A Great Day in Newcastle combines jazz with rock, hip-hop, drum and bass and spoken word, while drawing heavily on their experiences of growing up in the North East. Live their bass heavy sound mixes hip hop with Soft Machine.

The Newcastle identity is important because the new British jazz movement has been associated overwhelmingly with London. Much of its development took place through the capital’s venues, clubs and musical institutions, reflecting the extraordinary cultural diversity of the city. Knats demonstrate that the ideas developed within that scene are now being interpreted by musicians elsewhere, who bring their own influences and experiences to the music.

Their approach is also rather different from the celebratory, dance-oriented sound of Ezra Collective. There are heavier passages, more abrasive arrangements and a stronger rock influence, alongside the improvisation and rhythmic complexity associated with contemporary jazz. The inclusion of spoken word gives some of the music a particularly local character, connecting it to Newcastle’s working-class identity.

It would be a mistake to describe Knats simply as a northern version of the London movement. What makes them interesting is precisely that they aren’t reproducing the music of the performers who preceded them. They are taking some of the same influences and developing something different, which is how successful musical movements generally evolve.

The Mercury Prize has a long history of including jazz records on its shortlist, sometimes creating the impression that the genre is there principally to demonstrate the judges’ eclectic tastes. But Ezra Collective’s victory in 2023 changed that relationship, and Knats’ nomination suggests that contemporary British jazz has become an increasingly important part of the wider music scene.

The fact that the ceremony is taking place in Newcastle adds a pleasing geographical dimension to the story, although the significance of the nomination extends well beyond the city.

Where next for British jazz?

The appearance of new albums from Ezra Collective and Moses Boyd provides an opportunity to consider where the movement is heading.

Ezra Collective’s Here Because of Hope, released in September, continues their development towards a sound that moves freely between jazz, Afrobeat, hip-hop, reggae and soul. Collaborations with artists from outside jazz have become an increasingly important part of their approach, reflecting the extent to which the boundaries between musical genres have become less significant.

Moses Boyd’s Songs for Sinners, released at the end of October, takes the music in a rather different direction, continuing his exploration of the relationship between jazz, electronic production and the rhythmic traditions of Black British music. Boyd has always seemed particularly interested in what happens when the improvisation of jazz meets the structures and sounds of contemporary dance music, and his work provides a useful contrast with Ezra Collective’s increasingly accessible approach.

Taken together with Knats, these records demonstrate that the movement hasn’t settled into a single recognisable style. If anything, the differences between the musicians have become more pronounced as they have developed their individual approaches.

That is a sign of musical health. A movement that simply reproduces its original characteristics eventually becomes another genre with its own conventions and limitations. The musicians associated with We Out Here have instead continued to experiment, incorporating new influences and developing sounds that are increasingly difficult to categorise.

The rush of capital in music over the last couple of decades has given us streaming services, which allow us to access vast amounts of music. But they have also given us a bland age, and era where musical innovation is getting rarer. But despite this British jazz has flourished. Right now it is the only new musical style to emerge in the last decade or two.

And just like the Beatles before them it is an American art form recreated for a Britian shaped by immigration.

Leave a Comment